Does accessiBe, UserWay or AudioEye make your website ADA compliant?
No. An overlay adds a toolbar and some automatic adjustments on top of your site. It doesn't change the code underneath, which is what accessibility lawsuits test. The FTC fined accessiBe over its compliance claims, a small business is suing UserWay over its marketing, and a lawsuit settlement has said outright that overlays won't make a site accessible.
What an overlay actually does
An overlay is one line of JavaScript. When your page loads, it adds a widget, usually a round accessibility icon, with options like bigger text or higher contrast. Some also try to guess missing image descriptions and labels after the page has already loaded.
What it can't do is rebuild your site. The checkout field with no label, the menu a keyboard can't open and the product photos with no description are all still in your code. A blind shopper using a screen reader or a plaintiff's attorney running an automated scan still runs into all of them.
What regulators and courts have said
accessiBe: $1 million FTC order
In January 2025 the U.S. Federal Trade Commission brought a complaint against accessiBe over its advertising, and in April 2025 finalized a $1 million order with a 20-year consent agreement covering how the company describes what its product does.1
UserWay: sued by a small business customer
A small online florist that paid for UserWay and was still sued by a blind consumer filed a class action against UserWay, alleging the company misrepresented what its overlay does, including claims under Delaware's consumer fraud law. These are allegations, not findings, and the case was still active in 2026.2
AudioEye: named in a settlement
AudioEye sells manual services alongside its automated product. But in one ADA website settlement, the parties agreed that overlay products, naming AudioEye and accessiBe as examples, would not be enough to make the site accessible.3
Does having an overlay make a lawsuit less likely?
There's no evidence it does. Lawsuits named businesses with an accessibility widget installed more than 1,400 times in 2025.4 To a firm that files these cases at volume, the widget badge simply shows the site was never fixed underneath, and lists of sites running these tools are easy to compile.
What to do instead
- Find out what actually fails. Scan your real pages, including the cart and checkout, with the overlay turned off and on. That's the only way to see what it's hiding.
- Fix the code. Most failures on small stores are routine fixes for a developer: labels, image descriptions, contrast, link text and keyboard access.
- Keep a dated record. An audit, a remediation plan with dates and a published accessibility statement show you're actively working on it.
- Then decide about the widget. Many businesses remove it once the underlying issues are fixed. Some keep it as a convenience toolbar, but not as their compliance plan.
See what your overlay is hiding
Our free risk check tells you whether your homepage fails, how badly, and which laws that puts you at risk under, and whether your widget is fixing anything. Results by email in minutes.
Get my free scanCommon questions
Can I keep my overlay and still be compliant?
Keeping a toolbar isn't the problem; relying on it is. What matters is whether the code underneath meets WCAG 2.1 AA. Fix that, and the widget becomes optional.
Is UserWay or AudioEye better than accessiBe?
They differ in features and services, but every overlay works the same way at its core: it runs on top of your site after it loads. None of them changes your source code, which is what lawsuits test.
Will removing the overlay make me a target?
The widget doesn't hide anything from an automated scan, so removing it doesn't expose anything new. Fixing the underlying issues is what lowers your risk.
Sources
- U.S. Federal Trade Commission, final order against accessiBe Inc., April 2025 (complaint announced January 3, 2025).
- Lainey Feingold, "Another Web Access Overlay Company Sued by a Small Business," lflegal.com, updated February 2026.
- Adrian Roselli, "AudioEye Will Get You Sued," adrianroselli.com, February 2023, quoting the settlement agreement.
- UsableNet 2025 Year-End Digital Accessibility Lawsuit Report, as summarized by TestParty (testparty.ai).